Thursday, February 23, 2012

MIT Research: The High Price Of Losing Manufacturing Jobs

Study: Overseas manufacturing competition hits U.S. regions hard, leaving workers unemployed for years and local economies struggling.

The loss of U.S. manufacturing jobs is a topic that can provoke heated arguments about globalization. But what do the cold, hard numbers reveal? How has the rise in foreign manufacturing competition actually affected the U.S. economy and its workers?

A new study co-authored by MIT economist David Autor shows that the rapid rise in low-wage manufacturing industries overseas has indeed had a significant impact on the United States. The disappearance of U.S. manufacturing jobs frequently leaves former manufacturing workers unemployed for years, if not permanently, while creating a drag on local economies and raising the amount of taxpayer-borne social insurance necessary to keep workers and their families afloat.

Geographically, the research shows, foreign competition has hurt many U.S. metropolitan areas — not necessarily the ones built around heavy manufacturing in the industrial Midwest, but many areas in the South, the West and the Northeast, which once had abundant manual-labor manufacturing jobs, often involving the production of clothing, footwear, luggage, furniture and other household consumer items. Many of these jobs were held by workers without college degrees, who have since found it hard to gain new employment.

"The effects are very concentrated and very visible locally," says Autor, professor and associate head of MIT's Department of Economics. "People drop out of the labor force, and the data strongly suggest that it takes some people a long time to get back on their feet, if they do at all." Moreover, Autor notes, when a large manufacturer closes its doors, "it does not simply affect an industry, but affects a whole locality."

In the study, published as a working paper by the National Bureau of Economic Research, Autor, along with economists David Dorn and Gordon Hanson, examined the effect of overseas manufacturing competition on 722 locales across the United States over the last two decades. This is also a research focus of MIT's ongoing study group about manufacturing, Production in the Innovation Economy (PIE); Autor is one of 20 faculty members on the PIE commission.

The findings highlight the complex effects of globalization on the United States.

"Trade tends to create diffuse beneficiaries and a concentration of losers," Autor says. "All of us get slightly cheaper goods, and we're each a couple hundred dollars a year richer for that." But those losing jobs, he notes, are "a lot worse off." For this reason, Autor adds, policymakers need new responses to the loss of manufacturing jobs: "I'm not anti-trade, but it is important to realize that there are reasons why people worry about this issue."

-- Double trouble: businesses, consumers both spend less when industry leaves

In the paper, Autor, Dorn (of the Center for Monetary and Fiscal Studies in Madrid, Spain) and Hanson (of the University of California at San Diego) specifically study the effects of rising manufacturing competition from China, looking at the years 1990 to 2007. At the start of that period, low-income countries accounted for only about 3 percent of U.S. manufacturing imports; by 2007, that figure had increased to about 12 percent, with China representing 91 percent of the increase.

The types of manufacturing for export that grew most rapidly in China during that time included the production of textiles, clothes, shoes, leather goods, rubber products — and one notable high-tech area, computer assembly. Most of these production activities involve soft materials and hands-on finishing work.

"These are labor-intensive, low-value-added [forms of] production," Autor says. "Certainly the Chinese are moving up the value chain, but basically China has been most active in low-end goods."

In conducting the study, the researchers found more pronounced economic problems in cities most vulnerable to the rise of low-wage Chinese manufacturing; these include San Jose, Calif., Providence, R.I., Manchester, N.H., and a raft of urban areas below the Mason-Dixon line — the leading example being Raleigh, N.C. "The areas that are most exposed to China trade are not the Rust Belt industries," Autor says. "They are places like the South, where manufacturing was rising, not falling, through the 1980s."

All told, as American imports from China grew more than tenfold between 1991 and 2007, roughly a million U.S. workers lost jobs due to increased low-wage competition from China — about a quarter of all U.S. job losses in manufacturing during the time period.

And as the study shows, when businesses shut down, it hurts the local economy because of two related but distinct "spillover effects," as economists say: The shuttered businesses no longer need goods and services from local non-manufacturing firms, and their former workers have less money to spend locally as well.

A city at the 75th percentile of exposure to Chinese manufacturing, compared to one at the 25th percentile, will have roughly a 5 percent decrease in the number of manufacturing jobs and an increase of about $65 per capita in the amount of social insurance needed, such as unemployment insurance, health care insurance and disability payments.

"People like to think that workers flow freely across sectors, but in reality, they don't," Autor says. At a conservative estimate, that $65 per capita wipes out one-third of the per-capita gains realized by trade with China, in the form of cheaper goods. "Those numbers are really startling," Autor adds.

The study draws on United Nations data on international trade by goods category among developing and developed countries, combined with U.S. economic data from the Census Bureau, the Bureau of Economic Analysis and the Social Security Administration.

-- New policies for a new era?

In Autor's view, the findings mean the United States needs to improve its policy response to the problem of disappearing jobs. "We do not have a good set of policies at present for helping workers adjust to trade or, for that matter, to any kind of technological change," he says.

For one thing, Autor says, "We could have much better adjustment assistance — programs that are less fragmented, and less stingy." The federal government's Trade Adjustment Assistance (TAA) program provides temporary benefits to Americans who have lost jobs as a result of foreign trade. But as Autor, Dorn and Hanson estimate in the paper, in areas affected by new Chinese manufacturing, the increase in disability payments is a whopping 30 times as great as the increase in TAA benefits.

Therefore, Autor thinks, well-designed job-training programs would help the government's assistance efforts become "directed toward helping people reintegrate into the labor market and acquire skills, rather than helping them exit the labor market."

Still, it will likely take more research to get a better idea of what the post-employment experience is like for most people. To this end, Autor, Dorn and Hanson are conducting a new study that follows laid-off manufacturing workers over time, nationally, to get a fine-grained sense of their needs and potential to be re-employed.

"Trade may raise GDP," Autor says, "but it does make some people worse off. Almost all of us share in the gains. We could readily assist the minority of citizens who bear a disproportionate share of the costs and still be better off in the aggregate."



Contacts and sources: 

50 comments:

  1. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."


    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  2. Automatic Gates Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  3. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  4. Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."
    Automatic Gates, Automatic Gates Manufacturers, Automatic Garage Door Manufacturers, Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers, Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers, Automatic Motion Sensor Glass Door Manufacturers - India




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  5. Automatic Gates Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."
    Automatic Gates, Automatic Gates Manufacturers, Automatic Garage Door Manufacturers, Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers, Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers, Automatic Motion Sensor Glass Door Manufacturers - India




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  6. Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Automatic Gates Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."





    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."






    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  10. Automatic Garage Door Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."






    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  12. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."





    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  13. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    BEMCO Hydraulics,originally an Engineering Craftsman's shop in the late thirties has risen to be a premier producer of HYDRAULIC PRESS and Portable re-railing equipments. It is located in Belgaum,Karnataka,and a southwestern state in India.



    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.bemcohydraulics.net/

    ReplyDelete
  14. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."





    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/






    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  15. Automatic Gates Manufacturers


    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  16. Automatic Gates Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."





    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  17. Automatic Garage Door Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  18. Automatic Gates Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    pelase contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  19. Automatic Gates Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  20. Automatic Gates Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."



    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  21. Automatic Gates Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."



    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  22. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  23. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."






    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com

    ReplyDelete
  24. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  25. Garage Door Manufacturers

    L Marks is the one of the leading Manufacturer Company Provides Garage Doors, Remote Controlled Garage Door Manufacturers, Boom Barrier, Sliding Gate Openers, Swing Gates, Remote Controlled Curtains, and Industrial Rolling Shutters Manufacturers in India.




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.lmarkshouse.com/

    ReplyDelete
  26. Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  27. Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  28. this is a nve post and great iformation to share.

    Door manufacturer

    ReplyDelete
  29. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  30. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."



    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  31. Boom Barrier Manufacturers

    L marks House - garage doors made of MS or Aluminum panels, in single or multiple panels, top rolling or side rolling, skyLights, swing and side rolling gates, rolling shutters and boom barriers.




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.lmarkshouse.com/auto_sliding.htm

    ReplyDelete
  32. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."



    for more details
    please contact
    www.herculesautomation.com/aboutus.php

    ReplyDelete
  33. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers


    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."

    for more details
    please contact
    www.herculesautomation.com/aboutus.php

    ReplyDelete
  34. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers


    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    www.herculesautomation.com/aboutus.php

    ReplyDelete
  35. Benaka Automations is Manufacturers and suppliers are Remote control Gate, Rolling Shutter, Motorized Sliding Gate, Motorized Swing Gate, Motorized Garage door Manufacturers, Top rolling door, Boom barrier suppliers, Sensor door, Industrial Door, Bollards suppliers in banglore, India..
    http://www.benaka.co.in/automation/
    Remote control Gate, Rolling Shutter, bollard, Bollards Suppliers, sliding gate, Motorized Sliding Gate, swing gates, Motorized Swing Gate, garage door, Motorized Garage door, rolling doors,Top rolling door, boom barriers, Boom barrier suppliers, Sensor door, Industrial Door,

    ReplyDelete
  36. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    Boom Barrier | Automatic Boom Barrier | Boom Barriers | Suppliers
    Automatic Boom Barrier, Automatic Boom Barrier Manufacturers in Bangalore
    Boom Barrier Gates, Automatic Gates, Automatic Gates Manufacturers, Automatic Gara
    Biometric Fingerprint Device Manufacturers in india




    for more details
    please contact
    www.herculesautomation.com/aboutus.php

    ReplyDelete
  37. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade."




    for more details
    please contact
    http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  38. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    "Hercules automation is one of the leading brands in the market for Fabricated items, Boom Barriers, Garage Door , Rolling Shutters and a pioneer in the field of Remote Control Doors and Gates in south India for over a decade.""Automatic, Automatic Garage Door, Automatic Gates, Garage Door Manufacturers in India, Rolling Shutters Manufacturers in India, Boom Barriers Manufacturers in India, Motion Sensor Glass Door Manufacturers in India."


    for more details
    please contact
    www.herculesautomation.com/aboutus.php

    ReplyDelete
  39. Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers

    Automatic boom barrier - Automatic boom barrier manufacturers,Boom Barrier - Boom Barrier Manufacturers,Boom Barrier Suppliers ...
    Automatic Boom Barriers-Automatic Boom Barriers Manufacturers,Boom Barrier-Boom Barrier Manufacturers, Suppliers and Exporters .Automatic Boom Barrier Manufacturers in Bangalore, India | Justdial
    Automatic Boom Barriers - Rolling Shutter Manufacturer
    Automatic Boom Barrier Manufacturers in Delhi - Grotal.com


    for more details
    please contact
    www.herculesautomation.com/aboutus.php

    ReplyDelete
  40. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  41. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  42. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Automatic Gates Manufacturers

    Hi,

    i gone through your website about Automatic Gates Manufacturers its really good.
    you want additional information visit: http://www.herculesautomation.com/


    ReplyDelete
  44. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  45. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers
    Hi,
    i gone through your website about Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers its really amazing.if you want additional information about Automatic Rolling Shutters Manufacturers
    visit: http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  47. Automatic Gates Manufacturers
    Hi,

    i gone through your website about Automatic Gates Manufacturers its really good.if you want additional information about Automatic Gates Manufacturers visit: http://www.herculesautomation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  48. Buy Godrej Boom Barrier in India. Get best and cheap prices with installation guide. Know the features, application, technical specification, certificates and product comparison for Godrej Boom Barrier

    Boom Barrier || Automatic Boom Barrier

    ReplyDelete
  49. That was a great read! Thank you for sharing that. 
    Regards
    benakautomations

    ReplyDelete