Friday, February 25, 2011

When the Arctic Was Warm Naturally, Climate Change Briefing

Scientists are unravelling the environmental changes that took place around the Arctic during an exceptional episode of ancient global warming. Newly published results from a high-resolution study of sediments collected on Spitsbergen represent a significant contribution to this endeavour. The study was led by Dr Ian Harding and Prof John Marshall of the University of Southampton’s School of Ocean and Earth Science (SOES), based at the National Oceanography Centre, Southampton.

Fieldwork in Spitsbergen
Fieldwork in Spitsbergen
Credit: National Oceanic Centre

Around 56 million years ago there was a period of global warming called the Paleocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM), during which global sea surface temperatures increased by approximately 5°C.

The warming of the oceans led to profound ecological changes, including the widespread extinction of many types of foraminifera, tiny single-celled organisms with distinctive shells. Plankton that had previously only prospered in tropical and subtropical waters migrated to higher latitudes. Similar changes occurred on the land, with many animals and plants extending their distributions towards the poles.

“Although environmental changes associated with the PETM at low- to mid-latitude settings and high southern latitudes are well documented, we know less about these changes at high northern latitudes,” explained Dr Harding.

Information about the Arctic environment during the PETM has come predominantly from sediment cores drilled from under the pack ice on the Lomonosov Ridge (~ 88°N) by the Integrated Ocean Drilling Program (IODP Site 302-4A). However, these cores do not span the entire PETM and therefore do not provide a complete picture.

“Information from other Arctic sites is needed for a better understanding of PETM environmental conditions, such data can then in turn be used in computer models which will improve our understanding not only of past climatic conditions but also enhance our ability to predict future perturbations,” said Dr Harding.

To help fill this knowledge gap, Dr Harding’s team turned to a site (~78 °N) on Spitsbergen in the high Arctic. Here, 2.5-kilometre-thick sediments span the critical period. During the PETM, the site would have been at around 75 °N, the difference in position being due to the slow movement of tectonic plates over millions of years.

Through analyses of plankton and the chemical and magnetic characteristics of the sediments, they were unambiguously able to identify a 15-metre succession of exposed sediment representing the approximately 170 thousand year PETM event.

At the base of the segment they found the preserved remains of the cyst-forming dinoflagellate Apectodinium augustum, a planktonic species diagnostic of the PETM across the globe. In fact, the species was already present in Spitsbergen before the shift in carbon isotope composition formally marking the onset of the PETM, suggesting that environment change was by then already well underway.

Along with data from other sites, their Arctic evidence suggests not only that sea level began to rise well before the formal onset of the PETM, but also that it peaked about 13,000 years into the period. At the same time, increased surface-water run-off from the land dampened water-column mixing and led to stratification, with an upper freshened layer that overlay denser, more saline seawater beneath.

By carefully comparing their results with those from IODP Site 302-4A to the north, they found evidence for regional differences in the environmental manifestations of the PETM in high northern latitudes. For example, the evidence from the IODP site suggests that the sunlit surface layer of the ocean was often depleted of oxygen, the results from Spitsbergen suggest that oxygen depletion was largely restricted to the bottom waters and sediments. In addition, they found that pollen from flowering plants was scarce, unlike at the IODP site, suggesting that conditions around the Spitsbergen Central Basin may not have been conducive to the growth of flowering plants during the PETM.

“Because this geologically short-lived event is represented by such an expanded section at Spitsbergen by comparison to other deep water sites, this locality has provided us with opportunities for further high-resolution studies of the PETM, which we are currently preparing for publication,” concluded Dr Harding.

The researchers are Ian Harding, Adam Charles , John Marshall, Heiko Pälike, Paul Wilson, Edward Jarvis, Robert Thorne, Emily Morris, Rebecca Moremon, Richard Pearce and Shir Akbari of SOES, and Andrew Roberts of the Australian National University, Canberra.

Preliminary field work was funded by The Millennium Atlas Company Limited, and a second expedition with other members of the palaeo-Arctic Climates and Environments (pACE) group was funded by the Worldwide Universities Network.

In a related story,Professor Sir David King, former Government Chief Scientific Adviser and newly appointed Chair of the NOC Advisory Council, joined ITN’s Health and Science Editor, Lawrence McGinty, and leading scientists from NOC and the University of Liverpool discussed the latest research on climate change earlier this month.

The Science of Climate Change Briefing covered a diverse range of topics, including rising sea levels, increased carbon dioxide emissions and the spread of disease from animals to humans. The event attracted an audience made up of representatives of the scientific community, alumni and members of the public. Subsequent feedback has been extremely positive.

Chair of the Science and Technology Select Committee, Andrew Miller MP; discussed the outcomes and lessons learned from the investigation into the UEA’s so-called ‘Climategate’.

Professor Phillip Woodworth of NOC talked about understanding sea-level rise and variability. Professor Tim Greenshaw (University of Liverpool) talked about the UK’s energy requirements and how these can be met through alternative sources, and Professor Matthew Baylis, from UoL’s, Institute of Infection and Global Health shared his findings about the influence of climate change on the transfer of disease and how this was starting to impact on the UK.

Professor Sir David King, who is also the University of Liverpool’s Chancellor, discussed the key strengths of the UK’s science base in helping solve problems around energy efficiency, the spread of infectious diseases, and flooding.

Lawrence McGinty is a University of Liverpool graduate in zoology and reports on science and environmental issues for ITV news programmes. Lawrence and his team were awarded an Emmy for Best International News Coverage of the Mozambique floods in 2000. His entertaining talk addressed the way the media report climate change and how this has changed over the last five years.

Professor Ric Williams, Chair in Ocean Sciences at the University of Liverpool’s School of Environmental Sciences, said: “There is widespread public concern and confusion about climate change. In our lifetimes, atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide have risen, leading to a measured warming around the globe. Despite this warming effect, there are extensive regions of the Earth which are becoming much cooler or warmer linked to natural variability over the period of a decade, similar to changes in our weekly weather.”

VIP guests and speakers at the Climate Change Science briefing
VIP guests and speakers at the Climate Change Science briefing
Credit: National Oceanic Centre

A podcast is available at

Contacts and sources:
Dr. Rory Howlett
National Oceanography Centre, Southampton (UK)

Citation: Harding, I. C., Charles, A. J., Marshall, J. E. A., Pälike, H., Roberts, A. P., Wilson, P. A.,  Jarvis, E., Thorne, T., Morris, E., Moremon, R., Pearce, R. B. & Akbari, S. Sea-level and salinity fluctuations during the Paleocene–Eocene thermal maximum in Arctic Spitsbergen.Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. (2011).doi:10.1016/j.epsl.2010.12.043 

No comments:

Post a Comment